New Subgenres

a cat flying a biplane watched by a cat on the ground

Continuing my musing on what we can discover if we follow trends in the publishing industry, there’s currently a bit of chatter about the decline in the number of historical romance novels being acquired by traditional publishing. Apparently, historical romance authors are having to add other elements; that is, a bit of mystery, some paranormal shenanigans, even fantasy.

Genre blurring has existed for ages in historical fiction.

Look at steampunk, which never took off the way I thought it would. I don’t understand it. Re-imagining history is fascinating!

But maybe steampunk added too much. Maybe the key to weaving history into a novel isn’t to ornament it with new things, but to hack away at it till a new vision emerges.

Could the next big thing in historical fiction be important events told through an animal’s eyes? There is a lot of potential there. Say a cat intent on its feline activities but interrupted by its owner’s attempt to ::insert famous event, whatever it might be::


Speaking of books from history…

Janet Neel’s mystery novels are now available in ebook (she was also a British lawyer and a Peer in the House of Lords). They’re from the 1980s and 1990s, and so, they’ve become historical or vintage or retro or whatever you want to call the PAST THAT I REMEMBER! …ahem. Her books are beautifully written as well as well-plotted. I like some more than others. If you’re curious, you can dip into The Complete Wilson & McLeish Set.

Similar blasts from the recent-ish past now available in ebook include mystery novels by Charlotte MacLeod and Marian Babson.


Discover more from Caldryn Parliament

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Comments

7 responses to “New Subgenres”

  1. carriebeanbfe7fd85b0 Avatar
    carriebeanbfe7fd85b0

    I love the reimagining of history with steampunk, and I love the look of it, but I can’t think of any book where I’ve enjoyed it. I think that’s because it inevitably gets so bogged down in description that the narrative drags. It works so much better visually, in film or TV.

    Historical fiction can be fun, but also problematic because as the world gets more challenging, I lean into stories for escapism, and anyone trying to accurately portray history inevitably paints a picture where it isn’t great to be a woman. So I like my historical fiction to be more about the setting, less about the reality, and I love when fantastical elements are blended in.

    1. Jenny Schwartz Avatar

      Yes!!! I couldn’t agree more. Although I did find a steampunk story I loved. I haven’t re-read it in years so not sure how it holds up, but Cory Doctorow’s Clockwork Fagin was fab. (I think it’s still free https://www.amazon.com/dp/B006JR67HS/ )

      1. carriebeanbfe7fd85b0 Avatar
        carriebeanbfe7fd85b0

        Oh nice, I haven’t tried that one. And I thought of one I liked, too – T. Kingfisher’s Clockwork Boys was wonderful. https://a.co/d/6lRBomx

        1. Jenny Schwartz Avatar

          I haven’t been able to get into Clockwork Boys. I need to try again. Hopefully it was just an earlier bad mood on my part.

  2. Fran Avatar
    Fran

    Thanks for the reading tips! As a long term lover of actual historical fiction such as Austen and the Brontes, as well as Georgette Heyer (turning a blind eye to the ghastly racism and class-ism) I find I really don’t like the more recent historicals which are so often modern romances in fancy dress. The sole exception to that is Michelle Diener, who manages to insert current themes in a way that is not too jarring.

    1. Jenny Schwartz Avatar

      Michelle is amazing!!! (I am totally biased since she’s a friend – but she is also genuinely a brilliant writer and editor)

      I agree too about the modern stories awkwardly costumed up. When I find someone who actually writes non-jarring historicals I’m thrilled. Along the Georgette Heyer line, I enjoyed Dorothy Mack’s regencies when I found them recently, and since they’re in Kindle Unlimited, I binged them.

      I’d forgotten The Iron Duke! Ooh, yeah. Great series.

  3. Fran Avatar
    Fran

    Meljean Brooks’ steampunk novels combine so many genres! lots of fun, too.

Leave a Reply